Meta says it may pull encrypted services like WhatsApp from Canada if the lawful access bill passes unchanged
Meta has warned Canadian senators that it may withdraw end-to-end encrypted services such as WhatsApp from Canada if Ottawa passes the lawful access bill as is, citing that it forces insecurity in software.
Representatives from Meta spoke to a Senate committee on Bill C-22 (Lawful Access Act) on Monday night. Rachel Curran, head of public policy in Canada for Meta, was asked by senators if Meta will pull their services out of Canada if the bill is passed. Curran responded that Meta would "review all of our options."
Although no definite decisions have been made, Meta has made it clear that if the bill passes in its current form, there is a heated debate over how much access police should have to digital data. The comments come from a major messaging service provider, and place it firmly against Ottawa.
What Meta has raised with senators
Meta is raising concerns based on technical issues. “We cannot provide Canadians with end-to-end encryption services and simultaneously comply with the lawful access bill,” Robyn Greene, director of privacy and public policy at Meta, told senators, as reported by the CBC.
Curran raised concerns with the political implications. Previously in an interview with Bloomberg, Curran said that weakening encryption is a ‘red line’ for Meta. “This bill risks making the private sector an extension of government surveillance,” she said. Although more diplomatic in the Senate, when questioned about withdrawing her services, Curran said that Meta would “have to consider all of our options.”
Meta has raised similar concerns in the past. On May 7, Curran raised concerns to a House of Commons committee. She said part two of the bill “grants very broad powers to the government with insufficient safeguards and clarity.”
What the bill requires
Bill C-22 requires electronic service providers to make changes to their services in order to allow investigators to access user data, where police or Canadian Security Intelligence Service have legal authority to do so. It was passed by the House of Commons on June 18. It is currently with the Senate.
The main issue is with part two. This allows ministers to issue confidential orders, forcing companies to make changes to platforms to allow law enforcers to gain access. The bill was introduced independently on March 12, after previously being in a border security bill and facing harsh criticism. The government withdrew the lawful access provisions from this bill before re-introducing them in their current form. However, Ottawa deny that this bill forces companies to create a backdoor. The office of Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree states that the bill does not force companies to reduce security measures. The government also describe the bill as neutral regarding encryption. This is not agreed upon by Meta and other companies.
Why encryption is an issue
End-to-end encryption means that only the sender and receiver of messages can see their contents. Therefore, in apps such as WhatsApp, Facebook and Instagram, it is difficult for companies to allow police to view messages. If the messages are encrypted, the company is unable to directly open chats.
As a result, opponents to the bill say that part two of the bill directly reduces encryption. If companies are forced to allow investigators access to user data, encryption in the service is reduced for all users.
Many people use these apps to communicate regularly with family members, friends and colleagues. As such, concerns around the potential withdrawal of services from Canada are of interest to a wide audience.
Worries raised by experts
Ottawa says that a clause within the bill prevents systemic vulnerabilities, however technology leaders and cyber security experts disagree due to the general vagueness of the phrasing. It can be declined by service providers if it creates a systemic vulnerability. However, in the amended bill, it states that nothing in the bill should be interpreted as requiring a service provider to un-encrypt user information. Despite these additions, Curran told senators that “the core of encryption is protected...but other fundamental parts are vulnerable.”
Cryptographers and privacy advocates have long raised concerns around this issue. If a backdoor is created for police, it cannot be exclusive. Hackers in cyberspace and foreign intelligence agencies can exploit the same backdoor. Security experts expect malicious hackers and foreign spies to exploit any vulnerabilities created by law enforcement at some point in the future. Curran agrees, saying that backdoors in encrypted systems will create vulnerabilities that will be exploited by malicious parties.
Data retention requirements
The bill also means the government can require companies to retain customer data (including IP address and connection data). This includes metadata, which refers to information related to a communication (such as when, where and between whom) but not the content of the communication.
The retention period is less than originally proposed. Amendments made by the government mean that customer data can be retained for a maximum of 6 months, instead of 1 year (as it was prior to amendment). Mandatory retention is only required for certain types of metadata deemed necessary for investigations. The minister’s office have stated that the bill only allows limited retention of metadata, and does not allow retention of content, browsing history or social media activity.
Despite this, experts in privacy are still concerned. In May, law professor Michael Geist from the University of Ottawa said that the government is creating "a massive haystack of data", posing large privacy concerns to Canadians. Provisions on data retention, and giving access capabilities to law enforcement, have caused concern from privacy advocates, academics, tech companies and opposition parties.
Opposition from the tech industry
Meta are not the only company raising concerns. Google and Apple have both expressed concerns that Bill C-22 puts customer security at risk, and could cause a loss of end-to-end encryption. In May, Apple said that in its current form, the bill “undermines the privacy and security features that customers expect from Apple”. Apple said that it could force the Canadian Government to require backdoors to be put in place in products, which it would “never do”. Although changes have been made to the bill, Apple told CBC that “there remains a risk that this bill undermines” privacy features.
Apps focussed on privacy, and digital rights groups have also raised concerns. Tamir Israel, lead of privacy and surveillance at the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, has said that although changes have been made in June “the fundamental problems remain, with superficial fixes.”
Balance from Federal Privacy Commissioner
Federal Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne has expressed a balanced opinion. In a statement to the Senate on November 2, he said that although improvements have been made to the bill, additional safeguards are needed, particularly a narrowed definition of subscriber information.
Signal and Windscribe
Signal has given a firm response. The platform has said that it will withdraw from Canada if it cannot maintain its security protocols. In previous reporting, Global News found that several other privacy focussed platforms, including NordVPN and DuckDuckGo, have said they may restrict services, or withdraw from Canada if the bill is passed as is.
However, Windscribe, a no log policy Virtual Private Network (VPN) in Toronto, has committed to maintaining its no log policy regardless of what happens to the bill. No log policies mean that the company claims to not store information on what users do online. Signal and Tailscale are also set to speak at the same hearing as Meta, as reported in Bloomberg.
What happens next?
The bill is currently with the Senate. It was passed quickly through the House of Commons. In the public safety committee, it was passed just before midnight. Many amendments were left outstanding in the bill. The companies that would be required to comply with it are now giving their opinions to the Senate. There has been no announcement of when a vote will be made in the Senate. Meta has not made a decision to withdraw from Canada, nor given any time frames. This statement is conditional upon the bill being passed as is, and the only action Curran has mentioned is that Meta will “have to consider all of our options.”
Edit Profile
Help improve @KR

Was this page helpful to you?
Contact Khogendra Rupini
Are you looking for an experienced developer to bring your website to life, tackle technical challenges, fix bugs, or enhance functionality? Look no further.
I specialize in building professional, high-performing, and user-friendly websites designed to meet your unique needs. Whether it's creating custom JavaScript components, solving complex JS problems, or designing responsive layouts that look stunning on both small screens and desktops, I can collaborate with you.
Create something exceptional with us. Contact us today
Open for Collaboration
If you're looking to collaborate, I'm available for a variety of professional services, including -
- Website Design & Development
- Advertisement & Promotion Setup
- Hosting Configuration & Deployment
- Front-end & Back-end Code Implementation
- Code Testing & Optimization
- Cybersecurity Solutions & Threat Prevention
- Website Scanning & Malware Removal
- Hacked Website Recovery
- PHP & MySQL Development
- Python Programming
- Web Content Writing
- Protection Against Hacking Attempts
